Skip to main content
Appellate Insight
facade of the James R. Browning United States Courthouse in San Francisco

Private Equity Funding and Control of Appeals

Private Equity Funding and Control of Appeals

November 16, 2026
| By Zahra Bocek
a human figurine standing before many winding paths

A client loses at trial and wants to appeal. The lawyer sees a substantial appellate issue. But the investor funding the case wants a settlement: an appeal would cost more and delay repayment. Who decides?

California’s new AB 2305 prohibits covered corporate funders from interfering with litigation decisions, including advice about appeals. Signed September 20, 2026, it applies only to contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2027. For appellate lawyers, the difficult question is when a limit on funding becomes pressure to change strategy. (Bus. & Prof. Code, §§ 6134.4, 6134.14.)

How investors become involved

An investor may own a management services organization, or MSO. This company provides accounting, technology, or marketing services that the law firm pays for. Providing those services alone does not mean the MSO pays the firm’s litigation expenses. The MSO supplies business services; lawyers remain responsible for the legal practice. (Cal. Rules of Prof. Conduct, rule 5.4(b)–(d) & com. [2].)

Separately, an investor may advance money for a particular case’s fees or expenses and agree to bear the loss if the case fails. This is called nonrecourse funding, in which the investor is repaid only if the case succeeds. If the case fails, the law firm does not have to repay the money. (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6134.2(e).)

AB 2305 can reach either arrangement. To qualify as a corporate legal funder, a business must have been formed primarily to raise or manage capital. It must also participate in a litigation practice through ownership, services, financing, or management. A service agreement can therefore bring a qualifying investor within the law even if it does not pay litigation bills. The law also bars contracts allowing prohibited interference by entities the funder controls, which may include an MSO. (Bus. & Prof. Code, §§ 6134.2(a), (c), 6134.8(a).)

Who controls the appeal

California’s existing ethics rules govern what lawyers may allow a third-party payer to do. Rule 5.4(c) prohibits a lawyer from letting someone who pays for another person’s representation direct the lawyer’s professional judgment or interfere with the lawyer-client relationship. (Cal. Rules of Prof. Conduct, rule 5.4(c).)

AB 2305 imposes a prohibition on the corporate funder itself. A covered funder may not interfere with or try to influence substantive litigation decisions, including advice about appeals. It also may not control funding allocations or budgets that may affect case strategy. The statute treats this conduct as the unauthorized practice of law. (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6134.4(a)(1)(H), (2)(C).)

The difficult question is whether a funder is simply declining to spend more money or using its money to pressure the lawyer to change strategy. Consider two situations.

The funder refuses to provide more money. An investor commits $1,000,000 for trial expenses. After losing, the client needs another $250,000 for an appeal. The investor declines.

The funder withholds promised money. An investor commits to funding an appeal but later refuses to release the money unless the lawyer drops a particular argument.

The first concerns the limits of the funding commitment. The second uses promised money to pressure a change in strategy.

The statute does not expressly require a funder to finance every appeal. Yet it prohibits control over budget decisions that may affect case strategy. Its text does not draw a clear line between declining additional funding and using that refusal to control the case. An agreed funding cap therefore does not, by itself, resolve whether a particular refusal amounts to prohibited interference. (Bus. & Prof. Code, §§ 6134.4(a), 6134.10.)

Case funding remains available

These restrictions do not ban case funding. AB 2305 expressly permits nonrecourse funding so long as the arrangement does not otherwise constitute the unauthorized practice of law. (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6134.10.)

But preserving the lawyer’s independence is only part of the inquiry. The repayment terms must also comply with the general prohibition on sharing legal fees with nonlawyers. Repaying an investor from fees earned in a case can raise that separate concern. AB 2305 addresses it by providing that nonrecourse funding does not constitute impermissible fee sharing when all four conditions are met:

  • The agreement specifies the amount to be provided or a maximum.
  • The funder’s return is limited to a multiple of the amount actually provided, such as twice that amount, or an interest rate on it.
  • The agreement prohibits using the money to obtain future clients or matters, including buying leads or seeking referrals.
  • The money pays only fees or expenses of identified matters already underway or for which counsel has been retained.

(Cal. Rules of Prof. Conduct, rule 5.4(a); Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6134.10.)

Plan for an appeal before judgment

Because funding disputes can arise after a loss at trial, counsel should address appellate funding when negotiating the agreement. Does it cover an appeal? How much is available? What happens if the money runs out?

Clear terms help clients understand the resources available for an appeal. Those terms should preserve the lawyer’s independent advice and the client’s authority to decide whether to settle. A client may, for example, value overturning an injunction more than reaching a quick settlement. (Cal. Rules of Prof. Conduct, rules 1.2(a), 5.4(c); Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6134.4(a).)

Counsel must also plan around filing deadlines. Waiting for an investor’s decision does not extend the time to appeal. Apart from the public-emergency exception in rule 8.66, no court may extend that deadline, and a late notice requires dismissal. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.104(b).)

Violating AB 2305 can be costly. Contract terms that permit or facilitate the unauthorized practice of law under the statute are void and unenforceable. Attorneys who violate the statute face State Bar discipline. Clients may sue attorneys and corporate funders for $10,000 per violation or three times actual damages, whichever is greater, plus attorney’s fees and costs. They may also seek orders stopping the conduct or declaring their rights. (Bus. & Prof. Code, §§ 6134.8(b), 6134.12.)

Addressing these issues before judgment helps lawyers and clients evaluate an appeal’s merits with a clear understanding of its cost and who will pay.

For More Information, Please Contact:

zahra bocek
Zahra Bocek
Associate
San Francisco, CA