Skip to main content
Legal Alert

The Clock Runs Forward: A Filing Deadline Is Not a Damages Cutoff

The Clock Runs Forward: A Filing Deadline Is Not a Damages Cutoff

In DeVone v. Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC (Oct. 8, 2026, B339219) 2026 WL 3257753, the Second District Court of Appeal reversed a trial court’s ruling that treated the time remaining to file suit as a limit on the period for which plaintiffs could recover damages.

The dispute arose from an investor’s decades-long relationship with a brokerage firm and its financial adviser. After the investor died at 93, plaintiffs, representatives of his estate, brought claims against the firm and adviser alleging that the defendants had continued risky options trading and collected commissions despite the investor’s cognitive decline. They first pursued the claims in arbitration. After the arbitrators dismissed the claims without deciding their merits, the plaintiffs filed suit for breach of fiduciary duty and financial elder abuse.

The defendants raised a statute of limitations defense. The trial court applied the delayed discovery rule, which postpones the start of the filing period until a plaintiff discovers or has reason to suspect the facts supporting a claim. It also applied equitable tolling, which can pause the filing period while a plaintiff reasonably and in good faith pursues another remedy that puts the defendant on notice of the claim, and excluded the time spent in arbitration. By that calculation, the plaintiffs sued with 21 months to spare.

But the trial court did not simply reject the claim that the lawsuit was untimely. It used that 21-month window as a way to limit damages by concluding plaintiffs could not recover damages for conduct outside the window.

After the plaintiffs presented their evidence, the court granted nonsuit on both causes of action, relying in part on its conclusion that they had not shown harm within the 21-month window to which it had limited recovery. On financial elder abuse, it found insufficient evidence of a wrongful taking or harm, emphasizing the account’s gains. On breach of fiduciary duty, it found insufficient expert proof of excessive trading and again relied on the gains as showing no harm.

On appeal, the Court of Appeal reversed, explaining that the 21 months that remained as time to bring a lawsuit did not limit plaintiffs’ recovery of damages to that 21-month window. Determining that the accrual of the claim is postponed does not mean the trial court could limit the party’s recovery. The trial court had also made a separate error by choosing a discovery date despite conflicting evidence about when the plaintiffs knew or should have suspected wrongdoing. The Court of Appeal held that this was a question of fact, reversed that ruling, and remanded for a jury to decide it.

The defendants also tried arguing that the trial court’s limitation on recovery was justified under the continuous accrual doctrine, which provides that when a duty arises repeatedly, each new breach can start a separate filing period. This permits recovery for timely breaches without reviving time-barred ones. The doctrine did not justify the trial court’s damages cutoff after it had found the claims timely under the discovery rule. But if the jury finds an earlier discovery date that otherwise makes the claims untimely, the plaintiffs may still establish timely claims based on later breaches of a recurring duty.

The Court of Appeal reinstated the financial elder abuse claim, explaining that the account’s gains did not foreclose liability for commissions on trades the defendants knew or should have known were likely to harm the investor. The plaintiffs presented enough evidence for a jury to decide that question. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 15610.30.)

The court also reinstated the fiduciary duty theory involving tax and estate planning advice because the adviser’s actual services could give rise to duties even without a separate engagement or fee. It affirmed nonsuit on the excessive trading theory because the plaintiffs lacked expert evidence showing that the trading or commissions were excessive.

There are a number of practical takeaways from this decision. First, practitioners should not assume that the deadline to sue also limits the period for which a plaintiff can recover damages. If a plaintiff could have filed a lawsuit years prior but only discovered the wrongdoing within the applicable limitations period, their recovery will be for the entire period of harm. Be sure to build a clear record of when the plaintiff knew or should have suspected wrongdoing to support or challenge delayed discovery. Document any grounds for equitable tolling, including the pursuit of another remedy and notice to the defendant. For recurring duties, assess each breach and its filing period under continuous accrual. And finally, identify factual disputes that require a jury’s decision to prevent reversal and a new trial.

For More Information, Please Contact:

Patrick Burns
Patrick Burns
Partner
San Francisco, CA
Sacramento, CA
Arezoo Jamshidi
Arezoo Jamshidi
Partner
San Diego, CA
zahra bocek
Zahra Bocek
Associate
San Francisco, CA

Receive legal alerts, case analysis, and event invitations.

Join our mailing list